• Donate Now
  • Volunteer
  • Contact Us
Tuesday, February 7, 2023
  • Login
  • Register
Big Cat Rescue
  • Get Involved
  • Cub Facts
  • The Sanctuary Cats
  • FAQs
  • Contact Us
  • Shop
  • Videos
  • Donate
No Result
View All Result
Big Cat Rescue
  • Get Involved
  • Cub Facts
  • The Sanctuary Cats
  • FAQs
  • Contact Us
  • Shop
  • Videos
  • Donate
No Result
View All Result
Big Cat Rescue
No Result
View All Result
Home News World

Rebuttal to "Sell the Tiger to Save It"

BCR by BCR
August 27, 2006
in News World
0 0
0
0
SHARES
33
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare via Email

From the Director of the Campaign Against Tiger Trafficking (CATT):

August 18, 2006

Dear CATT Subscriber,

Tiger-farming advocates are turning up the heat on their campaign to see tigers farmed like cows and pigs. More than a few of you saw evidence of this on August 15, when The New York Times ran a prominent opinion piece entitled “Sell the Tiger to Save It” by Indian pundit Barun Mitra.

The placement of this op-ed, with its dramatic illustration, in the U.S. newspaper of record was an undeniable coup for the farming lobby, which hosted Mitra’s recent VIP tour of Chinese tiger farms. Even some of those who care deeply about wild tigers thought they may have heard a ring of reason in Mitra’s arguments. However, things are rarely as simple as they are portrayed by pundits.

Mitra argues that, because tigers breed like cats and sell — in the form of bones, skin, claws and teeth — for as much as $40,000, tiger farms can help the tiger “pay for its own survival” and “break the poverty cycle” of the tiger’s human neighbors, while eliminating “incentives for poachers.” Sadly, for wild tigers, he is dead wrong.

The only way in which Mitra’s scenario will alleviate poverty in the tiger’s domain is to stimulate poaching. Given that it can cost a poacher in India as little as one U.S. dollar to kill a tiger, his profit margin will be 2,000 percent even if he sells his dead tiger for a mere $2,000.

Meanwhile, farmed tigers, which eat meat daily to maturity, will cost thousands of dollars to produce. A good return on investment will require a selling price of at least $40,000.

If you are a user of tiger bone to make wine for arthritis, whose tiger will you buy in this time when the bones of wild tigers cannot be distinguished from those of farmed tigers? The wild one, which is better according to the tenets of traditional Chinese medicine and costs a small fraction of the farmed variety? Or the inferior farmed tiger at 20 times the price?

So, yes, perhaps poverty will be alleviated for some poachers — those lucky enough to bag one of the last 4,000 to 5,000 tigers left in the wild. After those are gone, which will be a relatively short time, the fat-cat tiger farmers can keep all the profits to themselves.

Mitra ends by saying that “if China decides to unleash the tiger’s commercial potential, the king of the forest might be more secure in his domain.” He draws a parallel between wild tigers and domesticated cows, buffalo, goats and sheep. “These are among the most exploited animals, yet they are not in danger of dying out.”

Not on farms anyway. And, yes, the world can certainly have all the farmed tigers it wants. Tigers on feed lots. Tigers bred and re-bred so quickly that their offspring must suckle on pigs and dogs. But what about wild tigers — the tigers who thrive and multiply in healthy forests filled with a full complement of other wild species to support a robust, sustainable Earth?

The simplest and most viable solution is to leave wild tigers alone in the wild and better enforce the long-standing ban on trade in tiger parts. Wild tigers will do the rest. The only humans who will lose out will be a handful of already-wealthy tiger farmers.

Thank you for your interest in saving wild tigers,

Judy Mills

Director – Campaign Against Tiger Trafficking (CATT): An organized response to an organized crime

; CONTENTID=2784&TEMPLATE=/CM/ContentDisplay.cfm

Tags: News World
Previous Post

Indian zoo gets lion from safari park

Next Post

Abused Ethiopian cheetah cubs get expert help

BCR

BCR

Big Cat Rescue is Caring for Cats and Ending the Trade

Related Posts

News World

Enrichment Program @ BIG CAT RESCUE!

May 7, 2022
115
Zanesville Massacre 18 tigers 17 lions 3 cougars gunned down  Rebuttal to "Sell the Tiger to Save It" jeg empty
News World

Zanesville Massacre 18 tigers 17 lions 3 cougars gunned down

October 20, 2021
10.3k
Vanessa Hudgens Shame  Rebuttal to "Sell the Tiger to Save It" jeg empty
Laws for Cats

Cub Petting Shame

September 12, 2021
6.1k
Snow Leopard  Rebuttal to "Sell the Tiger to Save It" jeg empty
News @ BCR

Save Snow Leopards

April 17, 2021
6.3k
Big Cat Rescue does bobcat rehab and release of native, Florida bobcats.  Rebuttal to "Sell the Tiger to Save It" jeg empty
Articles by BCR

GoFree

March 29, 2020
2.8k
Next Post

Abused Ethiopian cheetah cubs get expert help

Leave a Reply

  • Default Comments (0)
  • Facebook Comments

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Help Feed Big Cats

One of the best ways to help is through general donations that can be used however it is most needed at the time.To make a general donation just click the Donate Now button below.  This is the best way to give as it has the lowest credit card processing fees and is immediate help for the cats.

Give to Big Cat Rescue

If you prefer to donate via Pay Pal, please use this link: Pay Pal

Recent Articles

  • Insitu2021 January 17, 2023
  • Smell my beans! Priya tiger at Big Cat Rescue. January 13, 2023
  • Want! Kekoa and Makani rehab bobcats at Big Cat Rescue. January 13, 2023

Recent Comments

  • Deb Quimby on Koda Lioness
  • heather elliott on Sapphire
  • Jason Jenkins on Tiger Facts
  • Claire Pritchett on Koda Lioness
  • Deb Quimby on Jinx

Save Big Cats

Donate to Big Cat Rescue

Sanctuary Cats

  • Jaguars
  • Leopards
  • Lions
  • Tigers
  • Bobcats
  • Canada Lynx
  • Cougars
  • Ocelots
  • Savannah Cats
  • Servals

More from Big Cats

  • Big Cat Rescue is Live 24/7 on Webcams
  • Rescue Missions
  • About Big Cat Rescue
  • Big Cat Rescue News
  • Reviews
  • Our Recent Work
  • Sanctuary FAQs
  • Big Cat TV

Insitu2021

January 17, 2023
Smell my beans! Priya tiger at Big Cat Rescue.  Rebuttal to "Sell the Tiger to Save It" jeg empty

Smell my beans! Priya tiger at Big Cat Rescue.

January 13, 2023
Want! Kekoa and Makani rehab bobcats at Big Cat Rescue.  Rebuttal to "Sell the Tiger to Save It" jeg empty

Want! Kekoa and Makani rehab bobcats at Big Cat Rescue.

January 13, 2023

© Copyright 2023 BigCatRescue.Org. All Rights Reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Login
  • Sign Up
  • About BCR
  • Videos
  • Big Cat Facts
  • Cub Facts
  • Our Cat Stories
  • Sanctuary Cats
  • Shop and Save Cats
  • Volunteer
  • Donate
  • Abuse Issues
  • Contact Us

© Copyright 2023 BigCatRescue.Org. All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist