A photorealistic 16:9 image of a Eurasian lynx in the Scottish Highlands at twilight. The lynx stands alert near a forest edge, with rugged mountains and misty moorland in the background. In the mid-ground, a small flock of sheep grazes behind an electric fence, symbolizing coexistence. The atmosphere is serene yet evocative, capturing the mystique of rewilding and the harmony between agriculture and wilderness.

Thirteen centuries ago, a soft-footed predator vanished from the wild, forested slopes of the Scottish Highlands. The Eurasian lynx—an elusive, golden-eyed cat—was driven to extinction in Britain by hunting and habitat loss, its disappearance a quiet loss to the ecosystem. Now, for the first time in more than a millennium, conservationists are envisioning a future where this wildcat once again stalks the heathered hills.

But this vision of rewilding isn’t just a fairy tale of ecological restoration—it’s a complicated conversation about balance, responsibility, and the true cost of rebuilding nature.

A Silent Hunter’s Return

The proposal to reintroduce lynx to the Scottish Highlands comes from the Lynx to Scotland partnership, a coalition of conservationists, foresters, gamekeepers, tourism operators, and even farmers. Over nine months, they met 12 times, holding more than 50 hours of deep discussions. Their goal was not simply to release animals, but to carefully evaluate how lynx and humans could live together in modern-day Scotland.

Their findings are striking: there is sufficient quality habitat for a viable lynx population, and the return of these cats could help control Scotland’s booming deer numbers, which have doubled since 1990 and are damaging native forests. Moreover, lynx could curb fox populations, benefitting endangered birds like capercaillie, black grouse, and even the critically endangered Scottish wildcat.

Between Fear and Fact

Despite their potential ecological benefits, not everyone is thrilled by the prospect of reintroducing a large carnivore. Farmers, particularly those who raise sheep in the Highlands, fear for their flocks. Their concern isn’t unfounded—lynx have been known to prey on sheep and lambs in other countries where they’ve been reintroduced.

However, there’s context. The report points to success stories across Europe: in Switzerland, France, Sweden, and Norway, farmers are compensated for livestock lost to predators, including lynx. Between 2005 and 2012, the average annual compensation for losses due to lynx was €700 per animal—considerably less than the costs attributed to wolves, bears, or wolverines.

More importantly, many countries have shifted their focus from simply paying for losses to investing in preventative methods—like electric fencing, livestock guardian dogs, and improved herding practices—which have been proven especially effective with lynx.

Coexistence Isn’t Just Possible—It’s Practical

The Lynx to Scotland report proposes a robust framework that includes compensation for farmers, community consultation, and management strategies such as relocations or, as a last resort, lethal control. Their approach is not idealistic, but grounded in evidence from successful reintroductions across Europe.

They also address public safety concerns head-on: there are zero recorded cases of healthy lynx attacking people in the wild. These cats are secretive, twilight hunters who avoid human contact and prefer forests to farmland. Children playing in the woods have far more to fear from midges than from a lynx.

Indeed, an illegal release of four lynx earlier this year—without proper preparation or planning—resulted in tragedy when one animal died. This reckless act underscores why proper scientific management, not rogue idealism, must guide the rewilding effort.

Toward a Wilder, Wiser Future

The reintroduction of the lynx is not just about bringing back a missing piece of the ecological puzzle. It’s a chance for Scotland to lead the way in responsible rewilding. It's a story of restoring balance—not just for forests and deer, but for people too. Tourists are already drawn to the romance of the Highlands; imagine the thrill of knowing that a wild lynx is out there, silent and unseen, helping nature heal.

But this restoration requires us to compensate those who bear the cost. Farmers deserve to be heard, protected, and supported if they’re to share their land with an apex predator.

The lynx could be more than a symbol of lost wilderness—it could be a model of coexistence in the modern world. If we get this right, we’ll leave a landscape richer, wilder, and more resilient than we found it.

Let’s support conservation that doesn’t divide us, but unites us in protecting what matters—for the lynx, for the land, and for the legacy we leave behind.

Featured